Plenty Good Room for Possibility
Matthew 25:14–30 | Ingathering Sunday | November 15, 2026 | Mother Hannah Wilder
I wonder what you would do if someone handed you a million dollars and said, “Here. Take care of this while I’m gone.” Would you invest it? Spend it? Give some away? Hide it under your mattress? I suspect most of us would feel a tremendous responsibility to protect that money. And maybe a little terrified of losing it!
That brings us to today’s Gospel, one of Jesus’ more provocative parables. We’ve just heard how a wealthy man entrusts enormous sums of money to three servants. Two take risks and put the money to work. The third buries his share in the ground. And when the master returns, things get ugly for that third servant. He ends up in the outer darkness, where there is weeping and gnashing of teeth. Wow. Thanks, Jesus. What an uplifting Gospel for our stewardship celebration!
We need to be careful about automatically identifying this wealthy master with God. This man sounds pretty awful! He profits from other people’s labor and treats the frightened servant with extraordinary cruelty. Biblical scholar Carla Works reminds us that Jesus tells this parable as part of a larger conversation with his disciples about how they should live while awaiting God’s promised future. And her insight is powerful: Faithfulness means continuing the work of Jesus in the world. Jesus has spent his ministry feeding hungry people, healing the sick, welcoming outsiders, challenging injustice, and proclaiming God’s kingdom. Now he asks his disciples: What will you do with everything entrusted to you? Will you carry on this work?
What strikes me most about the servants’ story is the role that fear plays in determining what happens next. Listen to the third servant’s explanation: “I was afraid, and I went and hid your talent in the ground.” I was afraid. How many times have we withheld something valuable because we were afraid? Afraid of rejection. Afraid of failure. Afraid there wouldn’t be enough left for us if we shared what we had. Fear can make a hole in the ground look like a very sensible place to put something precious.
The first two servants carry on their master’s work. The third allows fear to stop him. He takes something with extraordinary potential and removes it from circulation entirely. He closes off every possibility of what that money might become. I wonder how often we do that. We bury our gifts because we think someone else can do a better job. We bury our vulnerability because someone hurt us the last time we opened our hearts. And sometimes we bury our money because we worry there simply won’t be enough.
I understand that last one. Money represents security, independence, and the ability to care for the people we love. My wife Kathy and I tithe. That means we give ten percent of our income to God through the Church. We support other charitable causes, too, but we commit that ten percent to the ministry of the Church. And I want to tell you something. This practice has changed our lives. Giving away that portion of our income has changed our relationship with money. We’ve discovered that even after giving generously, our needs are met. We still enjoy life’s little luxuries: Netflix, our beloved pets, and a wonderfully cozy down comforter! And we spend less energy worrying about accumulating more and more money. Of course, everyone’s financial circumstances differ. I share our experience because of the freedom we’ve found through this practice.
Jesus keeps inviting us into a different relationship with abundance. Throughout the Gospels, he describes a world in which generosity creates new possibilities. A few loaves and fish become a feast for thousands. A tiny mustard seed becomes a great sheltering tree. This is God’s economy, and it operates according to some wonderfully extravagant principles. Jesus calls us to plant seeds of generosity, knowing we may never see what grows from them. To show kindness to people who have done nothing to earn it. To love people who make themselves difficult to love and forgive people who have caused us real pain.
There’s an old story about two monks who spent years preparing for an extraordinary opportunity. They had been told that if they studied and prayed faithfully, one day they would receive an appointment to meet God at the top of a mountain. Finally, that day arrived. They set off together, full of anticipation. But halfway up the mountain, one monk fell and broke his leg. His companion stayed with him through the night, hoping he might recover enough to continue.
By morning, the injured monk had developed a fever. He clearly couldn’t go any farther. And his companion faced a terrible choice. He could continue up the mountain and keep his long-awaited appointment with God, or he could stay and care for his suffering friend. And that’s where the story ends. What would you do? Here’s what I love about that story: The monk has already reached the summit. He just doesn’t know it yet. Because the God he hopes to encounter at the top of the mountain is already present in the suffering person beside him.
And isn’t that exactly what Jesus tells us in the very next passage of Matthew’s Gospel? When we feed the hungry, welcome the stranger, care for the sick, and visit the imprisoned, we encounter Christ himself. Every day, we face opportunities to choose what we will do with our time, money, energy, and love. Every day, we can participate in God’s extraordinary economy of generosity.
And I think that’s a beautiful description of what we’re doing here at St. Paul’s. For months we’ve engaged in a season of discernment, listening to one another and asking where God might be calling us. Today, as we conclude our fall pledge campaign, we’ll bring our financial commitments for 2027 forward and place them in a basket on this altar. Each pledge represents resources we’re choosing to share so that we can continue the work of Jesus together.
What might become possible because of those gifts? Perhaps a child will discover that God loves them exactly as they are. Perhaps a grieving person will find companionship. Perhaps someone who has felt rejected by religion will find a community where they belong. Perhaps our neighbors will find food, friendship, healing, or hope.
And remember, the first two servants received different amounts, yet both heard exactly the same words: “Well done, good and trustworthy servant.” Their faithfulness mattered more than the size of their contribution. Some can make substantial pledges. Others have limited resources. Some cannot make a financial pledge at all. Every person belongs here. Every person matters.
Our stewardship theme is “Plenty Good Room.” There is plenty good room for all of us in God’s beloved community. And God calls us to help create a world where more people experience that room.
Which brings me back to my opening question. What would you do if someone entrusted you with a million dollars? Perhaps the more important question is: What will we do with everything God has already entrusted to us? Our money. Our abilities. Our compassion. Our time. Our very lives. Will fear convince us to bury what we have? Or will we take the risk of sharing it, trusting that God can do extraordinary things through our generosity?
Today, we have an opportunity to answer that question together. Because somewhere in our community, someone is waiting for companionship, for welcome, for a meal, for healing, for love. And when we share what we have to meet those needs, we may discover what those two monks discovered. The God we’ve been searching for has been right here among us all along.
There is plenty good room for everyone in God’s beloved community. And together, with God’s help, we can make that room. Amen.
